• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

CenterTao.org

taoism, taoist thought, buddha, yoga, tai chi, shakuhachi

  • Home
  • Tao Te Ching
  • Ways
  • Facebook Group
  • Blowing Zen

Instinctive Free Will

Instinctive Free Will-cheerWe easily acknowledge that animals and young children don’t choose their nature; they are born with it. Consequently, society doesn’t regard them as being responsible. With the onset of adulthood, that suddenly changes, and society then holds us responsible for our actions. As adults, we somehow miraculously acquire the power to choose “right” from “wrong” (see Free Will: Fact or Wishful Thinking?, p.587). It is rather obvious that this irrational rationale is society’s means of maintaining order. Civilization needs rules, and chapter 38 jabs directly at this contrivance. Note how each step in loss of the way has particular repercussions.

Superior virtue is not virtuous, and so has virtue.
Inferior virtue never deviates from virtue, and so is without virtue.
Superior virtue: without doing, and without believing.
Inferior virtue: without doing, yet believing.
Superior benevolence: doing, yet without believing.
Superior justice: doing and believing.
Superior ritual: doing and when none respond,
Normally roles up sleeves and throws.
Hence, virtue follows loss of the way.
Benevolence follows loss of virtue.
Justice follows loss of benevolence.
Ritual follows loss of justice…

Peeling Away the Pretense

Why did we decide that only animals act via instinct while humans have the power to act via free will? To me, this smacks more of an ideal promulgated to shore up the legitimacy of society’s rules. At a deeper level, I see this notion of free will as a projection of what Buddha called our “illusion of self”. This notion gives form and function to our species-centric ego. The idea of free will serves to makes us feel exceptional.

The idea of free will shows a wanton disregard for nature’s way. Perhaps this reflects the ignorance to which chapter 16 refers, Not knowing the constant, rash actions lead to ominous results. We certainly have our fair share of that blindness. Similarly, chapter 70 observes, Man alone is without knowing, and because of this I don’t know. Knowing self is rare, following self is noble.

Emotion: The Root of all Thought and Action

Emotion is where the rubber hits the road. As a species, we think up numerous ideals of progress, if not perfection. Take a moment to recall an ideal you hold dear. Does it not stem from some emotional need or fear? Perhaps you cherish the widespread ideal of peace-on-earth. I imagine this arises from an empathetic repulsion to suffering. Perhaps you hold out for something more mundane, like wanting to eat less or worrying that you don’t exercise enough. What we want or worry about in life arises from emotion, i.e., our core needs and fears. Alas, want and worry are easy mental activities that can mushroom without limit. However, they are seldom strong enough to initiate physical action, which is a good thing. Otherwise, we’d soon burn ourselves out. Indeed, even if free will existed, we don’t have sufficient wisdom to wield it.

Now, consider the desires and worries that you actually do something about. If you look closely, you’ll notice that the only time you do anything is when you feel emotionally compelled to. Emotion energy must reach a certain threshold before we actually put our money where our mouth is. Our experience with free will follows the same trajectory. We desire to have free will, so we imagine free will is possible. This is the hopeful where our mouth is phase. Anytime that ideal is tested and we fail, we come up with the necessary rationalization for why our free will failed us. This is the regretted inability to put our money phase.

Not surprisingly, we easily see through the excuses others plead, yet hold them to the same free will standard, often saying “You should have (insert ideal choice here)”. We play a marvelous game of self deception as chapter 18 describes, When the great way is given up, there is benevolence and justice; When intelligence increases, there is great falseness; or as D.C. Lau put it, When the great way falls into disuse there is benevolence and rectitude; When cleverness emerges there is great hypocrisy. We create the finest rationalizations our superior intelligence can weave together.

So, Instinctive Free Will It Is

Instincts are emotional drives arising from a brain’s core limbic system. These propel all vertebrate life on Earth to do what they do. The fact that this must also apply to humans is revealing. Simply put, an instinctive need to control our actions drives our belief in free will. Every animal feels a need to control its circumstances. I’d even venture to say plants feel this need too, although not via a nervous system, per se. The only difference is that plants and animals don’t possess the cognitive resources to turn that feeling into a belief. We do, and so we fool ourselves into thinking we have free will.

“So what?”, you might ask. For one thing, when we believe in free will, we can’t help but contend with ourselves, and with the world. Life becomes a constant battle between what we think should be and what is. Overall, there is less time and energy left for living effectively. As chapter 73 reminds, Nature’s way never contending, yet adept in victory. Some fear that without free will, we would just lie around doing nothing. Nonsense! Look at the rest of the animal kingdom. Does the lack of free will cause them to lie around doing nothing? All I see is superb natural efficiency.

Even as biological science continues to illuminate the mysteries of life, many continue remaining in the dark. What we need to believe drowns out any evidence to the contrary. We continue to think we can control life. Metaphorically, this is like a skyscraper with its penthouse in the clouds thinking it can control its foundation. The foundation rules; when it tilts one way, the rest of the building tilts with it. When it fails, the building fails.

A Pinch Of Science Is All We Need

Instinctive Free will2The Triune brain is a model of the vertebrate brain proposed by the neuroscientist Paul MacLean. This model identifies three structures added in the course of the brain’s evolution: (1) the reptilian complex, (2) the paleomammalian complex (limbic system), and (3) the neomammalian complex (neocortex). This model makes sense… up to a point anyway. Here are some brain science basics:

♦ Brains, and nervous systems overall, evolve in layers. Mammal’s brains have a core limbic system (a.k.a, the paleomammalian brain) and a cerebral cortex. The core is tucked away in the center of the brain and is primeval. It is where most of the basic functions reside, such as our sense of survival, fear, anger, hunger, sex drive, etc. This paleo brain makes its black and white decisions quickly with little hesitation. The even more primal brain stem at the brain’s base, controls reflexes and crucial, basic life functions such as heart rate, breathing, and blood pressure. It also regulates when we feel sleepy or awake.

♦ The top neocortex layer is a much more recent development in evolutionary terms. It is much bigger in humans than in other animals and is the part linked to intelligence. If the paleo brain tells us to be afraid because we hear a loud bang, the cortex will analyze the situation and decide whether we should run away or stay put, depending on whether the noise portends danger or not.

What actually makes decisions is the deeper question. Assuming that the neocortex does this can’t be accurate. After all, emotions arising from the lower layers are constantly influencing this upper one. All stimuli, both internal (e.g, memory) and external (e.g., loud noise), can potentially push our emotional buttons, which means we can only make truly rational decisions in the absence of all stimuli. This causes the brain’s mind to lose itself, so to speak.

Overall, the layered model lends support for my analogy above, i.e., when the foundation tilts, the rest tilts with it — the foundation rules! That is a hard pill for ‘Mr. or Ms. ego’ to swallow since they need to feel they are in control. That need arises naturally from our emotional paleo brain, (a.k.a, the limbic system). Put simply, our paleo brain does not need to see things as they truly are! It only needs to feel things and pass this on for the cortex to interpret… or misinterpret!

How Do We Manage This Instinct?

Human culture normally sees instinct and free will as being opposites. We believe animals merely act out of instinct, whereas humans act rationally through free will. This doesn’t hold up to either science or honest observation. It is clear to me now that the belief in free will is itself driven by an instinctive need (and fear) to control circumstances. Ironically, reality is what we believe is real, be they ghosts, gods, UFOs, or free will. So, is there any way to manage this deep-seated bio-hoodwink?

Before thinking about how we can better manage our biological reality, we might instead ask how we make it worse. Primarily, I notice we make matters worse by assuming we are in control, or that we can rise above our animal reality. This plainly reveals our species’ arrogance and ignorance of nature. Chapter 74 takes a swing at this streak of overconfidence…

A man taking the place of the killer killing,
Is said to be taking the place of the great craftsman.
A man taking the place of the great craftsman rarely never hurts his own hands.

The great craftsman is our primal nature. The man taking the place of the great craftsman is our presumptuous self-image (ego) taking the place of the killer killing. Once we finally come to terms with the science of this and confess our “sins” of arrogance and ignorance, we will be in a vastly better position to manage our reality.

 

Dec 15, 2013 by Carl Abbott
Filed Under: Observations Tagged With: emotion, fear, free will instinct, freewill, instinct, limbic system, Mr. or Ms. ego, need, reptilian brain, thinking, Triune brain

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Carl Abbott says

    Aug 29, 2022 at 4:22 pm

    Free will is the absence of control, letting go of the need for control, accepting that flowing with the Tao, one’s chosen path is always in harmony.

    The idea of there being a “one’s chosen path” is an example of the illusion of free will. Believing that humans are free to choose anything is a comforting story we tell ourselves. In fact, we are not different from any other animal on earth. Ironically, we only think (imagine) that we are, and relentlessly fabricate narratives to ‘verify’ it.

    On the other hand, if by “free will” you mean that all animals have this capacity, then I fully concur. Of course, that makes the ‘free’ aspect meaningless, which means it all come down to a will-to-live shared by living things.

    However, in my experience cultures view free will as solely a human capacity. We merely think we are different, and dare I say, uniquely so. We really are not any more or less unique than any other animal… meaning each species is unique in its own way.

    I assume this elitist view is driven by our illusion of self (ego). This would not be such a big deal if it weren’t for our disease, i.e., Realizing I don’t know is better; not knowing this knowing is disease.

  2. Michael A. Lewis says

    Nov 15, 2014 at 8:40 pm

    “Our thoughts of having free will are driven by an instinctive need to control our actions.”

    “Free will” is not control. Living spontaneously, one is free to do whatever arises of the moment.

    Free will is the absence of control, letting go of the need for control, accepting that flowing with the Tao, one’s chosen path is always in harmony.

    Free will is the opposite of determinism, as living in the Tao is the opposite of control.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Monthly Chapter 70 (pandemic era)

See previous chapter postings

Search

Overview

Is Taoism a Religion?   Read more...
What is Taoist thought?   Read more...
What is the root of thought? Read more...

Who is CenterTao?

CenterTao is a non-profit corporation founded in 1982.     Read more...

Subscribe via Email

Tags

addiction balance belief bio-hoodwink Buddha children civilization consciousness desire ego emergent property emotion expectations fairness instinct family fear food freedom freewill future happy hunter gatherer imagination independance instinct knowing language learning mind mysterious sameness need parents pleasure v pain religion responsibility science stress symptoms point of view tai chi tao thinking understanding what is tao worry yoga

Recent Comments

  • MosesK on Is Rock Conscious?
  • Carl Abbott on Alleviating the Hoarding Disorder
  • Carl Abbott on Instinctive Free Will
  • Erin on Alleviating the Hoarding Disorder
  • Carl Abbott on Small ‘t’ Taoists
  • J on Small ‘t’ Taoists
  • Carl Abbott on Buddha’s Truths Pertain To All Life
  • NoahPayne95 on Trump and the Mandate of Heaven
  • Peter on Buddha’s Truths Pertain To All Life
  • Ariel Avalos on The best tao? (road, way, principle, speak, think)

Past Observations

  • Taoist Thought
  • The Tradeoff
  • Buddha’s Truths Pertain To All Life
  • Trump and the Mandate of Heaven
  • Refreshing Redundancy
  • The Year Is 1915
  • We All Know We Don’t Know
  • Who are you? (Part V)
  • Who are you? (Part IV)
  • Who are you? (Part III)
  • Who are you? (Part II)
  • Who are you?
  • The Word Trap
  • Stressors of Comfort and Security
  • “Right state of peaceful mind”
  • What Climate Catastrophy?
  • Straight Poop on the Paleo Diet
  • Fear & Need Born in Nothing
  • Science Proves Buddha Right!
  • Alleviating the Hoarding Disorder
  • Amazon mother
  • Cultivating Character
  • Cultivating Ego
  • Passing judgment is healthy if…
  • Necessity is the Mother
  • Practice what you preach
  • Of Mountains, Molehills and the Supernatural
  • Civilized Insanity
  • Ancient Signs Of Modern Behavior
  • The Good Old Days
  • Modus Operandi
  • Alone with Thought
  • A proper sense of awe
  • CenterTao Group Anyone?
  • Loving Your Eco-System
  • Where does the fault lie?
  • Taoist secrets
  • Laws as Symptoms, not Solutions
  • Loss Aversion Management
  • Mind Over Milkshake
  • Flow Triggers
  • Naturally Racist
  • BRAIN
  • Managing Our Disorders
  • Bono & Musk on Creativity
  • The Harmless People
  • Born Again Taoist
  • Free Willers Anonymous
  • Instinctive Free Will
  • Stupidly Intelligent
  • The Proof is in the Pudding
  • A Wealth of Happiness
  • Natural Happiness
  • Is Happiness In Your Choices?
  • Profound Connections Enlighten
  • Religion… an Opiate?
  • Is Gen Y Unhappy?
  • Remember the Disease
  • The Pendulum Swings
  • You are Immortal!
  • A Rose By Any Other Name
  • Emotion Speaks… Literally
  • I Look, But Do I See?
  • Just like Us, Just like Them
  • Science’s Baby Steps
  • Worthy of a Noble Life?
  • Who says chickens are stupid?
  • Seeking Out Untruth
  • Earn It to Learn It
  • Counterbalancing I.Q.
  • Mind Run Away; Run Away Mind
  • “The rich suffer in comfort”
  • Self-Predation
  • Finding Your Original Self
  • Feeding the Worry Gene
  • Hold the Knowable
  • Good Enough Is!
  • Ponder Between the Lines
  • Soaking in Inspiration
  • A Tao of Parenting
  • Buddha’s Work
  • Insatiably Curious at 70?
  • Breathe Into It
  • Tao of Government
  • Will-to-Live, Free or Otherwise
  • Begin New Years with a smile
  • The Why Of It
  • The Truth vs. The Middle
  • Dumbfounding
  • A Taoist Creed
  • Of Free Will, I Am
  • Discomfort and Pain
  • Undecided? You bet!
  • Siren’s Song of Politics
  • “It’s the Economy Stupid”
  • Networks of Networks of….
  • Can we pull the plug?
  • Yamaguchi San
  • “Fixation on same same”
  • Beware: the Blind Spot
  • And Then There Was Fire
  • Tao and Democracy
  • What’s Not the Elephant?
  • Upping the Ante
  • A Word to the Wise?
  • A Bee with Personality
  • Necessity, the Mother
  • Guilt, Shame and the Name Game
  • The Secret to Happiness!
  • It Began Now
  • I am foolish of human mind also?
  • Seat of Consciousness
  • What Follows Loss of the Way?
  • Placebo Effect
  • Imagining a Better Way
  • Who or What Do You Trust?
  • Giving Your Life a Gift
  • The Only Safe Escape
  • Use Non-Responsibility
  • Be Careful What You Wish
  • Jack of All Trades, Master of None?
  • We only understand what we know
  • Two Paths
  • The Trans Tribal Tao
  • Resistance is Futile
  • A Brother is a Brother
  • Really, Have We No Clue?
  • Why?
  • Gone Fishin’, Back Soon
  • Check One Off the Bucket List
  • Opiate of the Masses
  • The Wealthy Poor
  • Dreaming the Way
  • Sobering up!
  • Oh My Aching Bones
  • The Utility of Knowing What You Don’t Know
  • Naturally Unnatural, Naturally!
  • Naked Thought
  • Success Thru Failure
  • I, Amoeba
  • Why Man is King
  • Ethics as an Emergent Property
  • Loss is Gain; Gain is Loss
  • “… Strive On Diligently”
  • Is Pain the Constant?
  • Ants Are Us
  • Feeling Animal-ness
  • Pleasure Isn’t Well Being
  • Is Rock Conscious?
  • See No Evil
  • Keep ’em guessing?
  • Thou Shalt Not…
  • You Are What You Own
  • Priorities
  • We!
  • You Know
  • Who You Are Determines Who I Am, & Visa Versa
  • An Improper Sense of Awe
  • Thoughts and Ducks Quacking
  • The poetry of it all
  • So, I’d like to ask…
  • Don’t trust anyone under 60
  • Imagination knows no end
  • In Praise Of Nothing
  • It’s Simply Nature’s Way
  • The Truth About Lies
  • It’s Time We Changed Our Name
  • Fear Rules
  • Nothing’s Certain but Death and…
  • Reward, Fear & Need
  • He Who Conquers Self
  • Democracy as Myth
  • So, You Want Enlightenment, Eh?
  • When Is Attachment Good?
  • Let Sleeping Dogs Lie
  • The Story Trumps Truth
  • Water in Mind
  • Why God?
  • Playing With Dolls
  • Belief in Nothing is Dangerous
  • Illusions, Everywhere I Think
  • Wandering Mind Is Unhappy Mind
  • Love
  • Small ‘t’ Taoists
  • Beyond Spooky
  • My Battle With Tobacco
  • John Cleese, a ‘Taoist’?
  • The Nutty Things We Do
  • A Symptom’s Point Of View
  • Fear Is The Bottom Line
  • Change we can believe in?
  • Science, Religion, Truth
  • Children Know What Adults Forget
  • The Spirit of Yoga
  • The less I think, the more I know
  • Exquisite Balance
  • Skullduggery is rampant in nature
  • What Shapes How You Think?
  • Tao As Emergent Property
  • Balancing Difference With Similarity
  • Thinking clouds consciousness
  • Where Is Freedom?
  • Decisions Decisions
  • Poor Thais And Rich Swedes
  • Time’s Arrow
  • Desire and Contentment
  • Learning What You Know
  • We’re Not So Different After All
  • Chairs: One of Our Big Mistakes
  • Gossip, Hysteria, News
  • The Family Purse
  • Swarm Savvy
  • SETI… Quixotic SETI
  • The Worry Gene
  • Odds Are, It’s Wrong
  • Bathtub Tai Chi
  • How the Hoodwink Hooks
  • Omega-3 and Vitamin D
  • He Who Speaks Does Not Know, but…
  • Hunger: A Natural Stimulant
  • Know Truth, Live True
  • Why Not Protest To Raise Taxes?
  • Self Integrity, Slime, and Karma
  • A How-To for Extinguishing Self
  • Significant Others
  • Headstands and Apes
  • The Future Takes Care of Itself
  • Teachers and Students
  • Are You As Happy As You Should Be?
  • Keeping Birthday Happy
  • Why Do Idiot Savants Run Things?
  • Trust But Verify
  • Are You A Beliefaholic?
  • Sage Advice from Wall Street
  • Of Course It’s Alive!
  • What Am I Doing?
  • I understand, but do I know?
  • Just In: We’re All Nuts!
  • The Future is Now!
  • Peeking Through the Covers
  • Innately Ethical
  • Can You Believe What You See?
  • Suicide Just Doesn’t Work
  • A Hypochondriac’s Miracle Cure
  • An Essential Taoist Secret
  • Just How Big Is The Gap?
  • The Theory of God
  • Who is Right?
  • You Are Who You Are By Default
  • Cave Man Shakuhachi?
  • Into the Jungle?
  • Swimming Tai Chi Spermatozoa Style
  • Are you out of touch with nature?
  • It was a dark and stormy night…
  • Cease Treading Water and Just Sink
  • Enjoy What You Do – or – Do What You Enjoy?
  • The Glare Hides ‘Out There’ From View
  • The illusion of ‘moment’
  • Consciousness Physics
  • A Taoist Solution to Gay Marriage
  • Emotion Clear-cuts Perception
  • Right Mindfulness, Attentiveness, and Concentration?
  • The best tao? (road, way, principle, speak, think)
  • The trick lies in not believing, yet believing
  • What is ‘the Tao’ actually?
  • Think what you believe? Believe what you think?
  • Yin Yang, Nature’s Hoodwink
  • Public Tantrums
  • Understanding Understanding
  • Wealth plays out in odd ways
  • Peaches and Pleasure
  • Looking Through the Looking Glass
  • Even a little progress is freedom from fear
  • Religion: The best placebo?
  • Correlation’s ‘Prime Directive’
  • The Cost of Compassion
  • Can you say what you think?
  • Grinding Out Correlations
  • “Do you believe in angels?”
  • The Amazonian ‘Taoists’
  • Is Enlightenment Something or ???
  • Family Life
  • Who’s a Sage?
  • The Gifts Given – Paid In Full
  • King Kiwi
  • Blowing with the sea
  • In praise of kale
  • Always be a beginner
  • It’s Like Magic!
  • How do we know what is true?
  • Am I Bored or Just Content?
  • Do Good Christians Make Good People?
  • PS
  • The Decider
  • Peeking in on Nature’s Hoodwink
  • How to Know You’re Happy
  • It Is Spooky
  • Of What Is The Taoist Model Symptomatic?
  • Is ‘Free Will’ the Only Option?
  • Butterflies have wings; we have minds
  • Mind in Body in Mind in Body…xin
  • Such Synergy
  • Where There’s Passion (fire), There’s Blindness (smoke)
  • Seeing the world ‘out there’
  • Schrödinger’s cat
  • Tai Chi Video
  • Life Is Struggle, Happiness Is Contentment
  • What’s With All The Hair?
  • Tao Views of the Dow
  • Biology’s Blinders: WYSIWYG
  • Those Who Speak Do Not Know. So, Why Speak?
  • Welcome to CenterTao.org 2.0!

Postscript

Here is 2022’s Postscript.

My 80-year-old mind continues poking deeper; however, I’ll not be updating this website any longer… There’s enough already… who needs more?

For those seriously interested, see Taoist Thought (which sells at cost). I intend to continue updating this book with my latest observations and revisions until I draw my last breath.

2004-2015 Forum Archive

Click here to browse a read-only archive of all discussion that took place on this site between 2004 and 2015; over 3000 posts!

Copyright © 2023 Carl Abbott · Log in